The lawsuit was brought by Art Works, Inc., an entity that owns Marianne Boesky Gallery, in the Supreme Court of New York. It centered around a bronze sculpture that went unnamed in the lawsuit and a debate over who owned that work.
Marianne Boesky Gallery represented Al-Hadid until 2019, according to the suit, which said their arrangement was exclusive. Al-Hadid, whose work is owned by institutions including the Whitney Museum and the Speed Art Museum, has since joined Kasmin gallery in New York and Berggruen Gallery in San Francisco. She is known for her paintings and sculptures that explore states of transformation.
According to Marianne Boesky Gallery, when Al-Hadid left the gallery’s roster in 2019, she owed them a “significant six-figure sum.” She and the gallery allegedly entered into a settlement agreement, but a dispute arose when they could not agree on the ownership of the sculpture in question. The gallery claimed it had an interest in the work because it had advanced money for its fabrication.
In his decision on Tuesday, Justice Louis L. Nock said that the gallery’s dispute over the ownership was based partly in a contract whose language he called “unambiguous.”
The contract “does not confer or transfer an ownership interest in the sculptures to” Marianne Boesky Gallery, he wrote.
In a statement to ARTnews, Paul Cossu, a lawyer representing Marianne Boesky Gallery, said, “To allow Ms. Al-Hadid to retain the entirety of the eventual sale proceeds without paying the gallery its share would be unjust, both legally and morally, punishes the gallery for being supportive of the artist when the artist could not afford to fabricate the sculpture, and does not reflect the agreement that was reached with the artist. The gallery is appealing the decision.”
“The gallery’s claim of ownership by virtue of a profit-sharing agreement was totally baseless,” said Wendy Lindstrom, Al-Hadid’s lawyer. “The judge not only dismissed Marianne Boesky’s case, but issued a resounding ruling that protects the rights of all artists.”